3 Materials For Church Roof Replacements: Pros And Cons

Posted on May 20, 2023

Estimated Reading Time : 5 Min.

Share Now :

church roof replacement

Though often unnoticed, the roof of a church plays a vital role in protecting the faithful and preserving the sanctity of the space. Like any other roof, church roofs also have a limited lifespan and eventually need to be replaced. When it comes to church roof replacement, there are several materials available. 

When the time comes for a roof replacement, the choice of materials becomes a decision of paramount importance. In this article, we explore three great materials that can be used for church roof replacements and explain the pros and cons of each. Join us as we delve into a world where strength, beauty, and practicality meet to safeguard those seeking solace within their sacred walls. 

Church Roof Replacements: An Overview

Replacing a church roof is a significant investment and can be a daunting task. Church roofs are usually steep and complex, making the installation process a bit more challenging than regular residential and commercial buildings. However, a well-installed church roof can last for many years and save you a lot of money in the long run.

The first step in a church roof replacement is to determine the type of roofing material that best suits your church’s needs and budget. There are several roofing materials available for church roofs, including slate, metal, and asphalt shingles.

Each material has its benefits and drawbacks, and the choice of material will depend on several factors, such as your budget, climate, and architectural style. 

Also Read: The Church Roof Repair Checklist: Steps to Take for a Successful Project

Materials To Consider For Your Church Roof

Here are our best roofing materials that you can choose from for replacing your church roof. 

#1 Slate

Slate is a natural stone material that has been used for centuries in roofing. Though you may not see them much on residential properties, most churches have slate roofs installed. 

A slate roof is known for its durability, longevity, and fire resistance. This material can last up to 100 years or more with proper maintenance. Slate roofs are also aesthetically pleasing and can enhance the architectural style of your church building.

Slate roof
slate roof

Now let’s take a look at the pros and cons of a slate church roof: 

Pros Of A Slate Roof

Unparalleled Durability: 

Slate roofs are renowned for their exceptional lifespan, often lasting over a century with proper installation and maintenance. This longevity makes slate an excellent investment, providing enduring protection for generations to come.

Aesthetic Beauty: 

The distinctive appearance of a slate roof lends an air of elegance and prestige to any church. With its natural variation in color and texture, slate creates a visually striking and captivating roofscape that harmonizes with the architectural style and historical significance of a church.

Cons Of A Slate Roof

Cost Considerations: 

While the benefits of a slate roof are undeniable, it is essential to acknowledge that slate is a premium material, typically commanding a higher price tag compared to other roofing options. 

#2 Metal Roofing

While slate is a commonly used roofing material for many churches, it is important to note that the durability of the materials used in the past may not be as reliable today. As an alternative, you may want to consider metal roofing for your church’s roofing system.

Metal roofs have become increasingly popular for church roof replacements over the years. They are durable, lightweight, and energy-efficient. Metal roofs can last up to 50 years or more with proper maintenance. 

In addition to traditional metal roofing, another noteworthy option to consider is stone-coated metal roofing. This variant of metal roofing combines the strength and longevity of metal with the aesthetic appeal of traditional materials, such as slate or clay tiles.


Let’s go over some benefits and limitations of a metal roofing system. 

Pros Of A Metal Roof

Durability and Longevity: 

Metal roofs are renowned for their exceptional durability, often lasting 50 years or more with proper installation and maintenance. They are resistant to harsh weather conditions, including strong winds, heavy rain, and snow, providing reliable protection for a church.

Energy Efficient:

You can make your church energy efficient if you install a metal roofing system. Metal roofs contribute to improved energy efficiency by reflecting solar heat and reducing cooling costs during hot summers. This will keep the congregation inside quite comfortable.

Cons Of A Metal Roof

Initial Cost: 

The upfront cost of a metal roofing system can be higher compared to other materials like asphalt shingles. However, it’s essential to consider the long-term benefits and lifespan of a metal roof, which can offset the initial investment over time.

Noise Concerns: 

Without proper insulation and underlayment, metal roofs can be susceptible to noise during heavy rain or hailstorms. However, incorporating insulation materials during the installation process can reduce these concerns.

#3 Asphalt Shingles

Asphalt shingles are the most common roofing material for residential buildings and have been for years. But you might be thinking, what are asphalt shingles doing in this list of the best materials for a church roof replacement? 

While they may not possess the same longevity or prestige as materials like slate or metal, asphalt shingles can provide adequate protection and a visually pleasing appearance, allowing churches to fulfill their roofing needs while staying within their financial means. 

Over the years, asphalt shingles have gone through tremendous developments. They are now much more durable and appealing. Some quality shingles now come with effective wind and algae resistance warranties. Asphalt shingles can also last up to 30 years or more with proper maintenance. 

Asphalt shingles
Asphalt Shingles

Pros Of Asphalt Shingles

An Affordable Roofing Material: 

Asphalt shingles are among the most cost-effective roofing materials available, making them a budget-friendly option for churches with limited financial resources. The lower upfront cost can allow for greater flexibility in the budget for other church needs.

Also Read: Top 5 Weathered Wood Shingles 2023

Wide Range of Styles and Colors:

Asphalt shingles are available in a variety of colors, styles, and designs, allowing churches to select a look that complements their architectural style and desired aesthetic. This versatility makes it easier to achieve a cohesive and visually appealing appearance for the church’s exterior.

Cons Of Asphalt Shingles

Limited Lifespan: 

While asphalt shingles are durable, their lifespan typically ranges from 20 to 30 years, depending on the quality of the shingles, climate, and level of maintenance. This is lower when you compare them to other roofing materials we discussed like slate or metal. Due to this reason, they may require more frequent replacements over the lifetime of the church.

Vulnerability to Extreme Weather: 

While asphalt shingles can withstand moderate weather conditions, they may be more susceptible to damage if you live in an area that has severe weather with high winds, extreme temperature fluctuations, or heavy storms. It is important to choose shingles with appropriate wind ratings and consider local weather patterns.

You Can Trust Us With Your Church Roof Replacement 

In conclusion, choosing the right material for your church roof replacement is crucial. 

Therefore, it is essential to work with a professional church roofing company who can guide you through the process and help you make an informed decision. This is where the team at Kickapoo Roofing can come to your aid. 

Whether you choose slate, metal, or asphalt shingles, our team can install the best church roof that will provide many years of protection and enhance the beauty of your building. Don’t hesitate to invest in the best roofing material for your church’s needs and budget. Contact us today at (608) 352-8688 to learn more. 

church roof replacement
Skip to content