Top 5 Weathered Wood Shingles Reviewed

Posted on December 2, 2022

Estimated Reading Time : 7 Min.

Share Now :

Weathered wood Shingles Reviewed

From their humble beginning as traditional shingles manufactured with a single asphalt layer to thicker, more durable, and color-enhanced options, asphalt shingles have come a long way in the industry.

Weathered wood shingles are a popular choice for homeowners who want to give a rustic, natural touch to their homes. This post will review five of the best-weathered wood shingles on the market and highlight their key features and benefits. Whether you’re looking to replace your old roof or add a touch of character to your home’s exterior, weathered wood shingles are sure to impress. Read on to learn more and find the perfect option for your home!

What Are Weathered Wood Shingles?

In general, weathered wood is a type of wood that has been weathered or distressed to give it a rustic look. Homeowners love the rough texture of this wood because it looks great, and is durable.

Weathered wood shingles are a type of dimensional, or architectural, asphalt shingle that resembles the same color and dimension as natural wood shingles, but at a much lower price.

Top Asphalt Shingle Manufacturers

Asphalt shingles are one of the highest-selling roofing materials available on the market, making competition high in the shingle industry. There are a lot of high-quality roof shingle manufacturers offering great asphalt shingles, but below are some of the best companies:


GAF is one of the best shingle manufacturers in America. They offer a wide variety of asphalt shingles that cater to every group and segment of the market.

In 1991, GAF introduced high-definition shingles with its proprietary granule technology which provided more shadows, and color patterns, to their lines of shingles. Since then, the company has constantly been developing products in roofing and related industries. Its top shingle lines include the Timberline HDZ, Camelot II, and Stateline shingles.


Image source: gaf. Com


Tamko is a company that specializes in the manufacturing of roofing and building products. Founded in 1944, the company is based in Missouri and has grown to become one of the largest roofing manufacturers in the United States. Tamko offers a wide range of roofing products, including asphalt shingles, metal roofing shingles, and other building products. Overall, the company is known for its high-quality products and commitment to sustainability.


Image source: tamko. Com

Atlas Roofing

Atlas Roofing Corporation manufactures building materials, including roofing shingles. The company was founded in 1981 and is based in Georgia. Atlas offers a wide range of roofing shingles in different styles, colors, and sizes to suit various architectural styles. Some of their popular shingle options include the Atlas StormMaster Shake, and the Atlas Pinnacle Pristine, a high-performance shingle with a modern design and good warranties.

Atlas roofing

Image source: atlasroofing. Com


Malarkey is a U.S.-based roofing manufacturer that has facilities located in Oregon, California, and Oklahoma. The company specializes in quality asphalt shingles, but they also manufacture ice and water barriers, as well as roof underlayments.

Malarkey has always been a leader in innovation. The company was the first to launch SBS polymer-modified asphalt roof shingles, and they also introduced the use of upscale rubber and plastics that help reduce waste in the environment. They are also part of the National Roofing Contractors Association (NRCA)


Image source: malarkeyroofing. Com


CertainTeed is one of the largest manufacturers of building materials, including roofing shingles. The company was founded in 1904 and is a subsidiary of Saint Gobain, one of the top manufacturers and a household name in America. Its Landmark series of shingles have been a benchmark in the shingle industry.


Image source: certainteed. Com

Best Weathered Wood Shingles For 2023

From what you’ve read in the above sections, it’s clear that the weathered wood shingle is one of the best, and most popular asphalt roofing shingles available on the market. All the top manufacturers offer their own range of weather wood shingles, so we’ve provided you with some of our top choices.

GAF Timberline HDZ Shingles

Our Rating: 9.5

Timberline HDZ Shingles are one of GAF’s best-selling roof shingles, and the most popular in the U.S. This is an architectural shingle that is loaded with features and has a pleasing look.

They are made with a durable laminated construction that helps to protect against the elements, including high winds and heavy rain. These shingles are available in a range of colors to match any home’s exterior with ease, the most exciting one being the weathered wood-colored shingle.

These shingles also come with a lifetime limited warranty, giving you peace of mind that these durable shingles will protect your roof for years to come.

Features of GAF’s Timberline HDZ Weathered Wood Shingles.

  • GAF weathered wood shingles come with StainGuard Plus™ Algae Protection, which helps protect the roof from blue-green algae discoloration. To know more about color options for your roof, visit our blog on GAF shingle colors.
  • The layer lock technology makes the shingles more durable and secure

Shingle Warranties

  • GAF Lifetime Limited warranty available.
  • Warranty that helps protect the shingles from algae stains for up to 25 years.

Malarkey’s Legacy Shingles

Our Rating: 9.5

Malarkey Legacy shingles have been seeing a surge in popularity in recent years that is due to both their aesthetic appeal, and durability.

The Legacy shingle is designed in the popular architectural style and made with industry-leading NEX® Rubberized Asphalt. This process combines rubberized asphalt with plastic polymers, which give the Malarkey shingles extra strength.

It delivers superior all-weather resilience, a Class 4 hail impact rating, and includes granules that help clean the air of emission pollutants. When it comes to performance, these shingles comply with some of the highest industry standards.


  • Offer 50% more adhesion than traditional roof shingles and has a nailing area that’s twice as large as the competitors
  • Class A fire rating and Class 4 Impact rating
  • Environmentally friendly shingles that use upcycled rubber and plastic

Landmark shingles By CertainTeed

Our Rating: 9

Landmark shingles from CertainTeed are today’s most durable and versatile asphalt shingles on the market. With a dual-layered design that emulates the look of real wood shake, Landmark shingles offer the heaviest weight and widest array of color options in their class, allowing you to create or re-create the ideal look for your home with confidence.

These shingles are constructed with CertainTeed’s premium roofing technologies, such as their Quadrabond technology, which keeps the shingle layers secure and helps them stand strong under high wind gusts and storms. The shingles also come with a 10-year StreakFighter® warranty against black streaks, and a 15-year wind-resistance warranty up to 110 mph.


  • Strong and durable 2-piece laminated fiberglass construction
  • Lifetime limited warranty that is also transferable
  • Wind resistance of 110 mph, upgradable to 130 mph

Tamko’s Heritage Shingles

Our Rating: 8.5

Tamko’s shingles are known for their style statement. The company’s Heritage series has a lot of beautiful and detailed color options, one being the weathered wood option. With its natural beauty and rustic appeal, the weathered wood shingle color from Tamko will never go out of style. The brown base is accented with lighter browns and earthy clay to create a sturdy and cozy look.

The Heritage range of laminated asphalt shingles is equipped with Class A fire resistance, and wind resistance. You can also find weathered wood shingles in Tamko’s most popular shingle line, Titan XT.


  • Resemble a classic wood shake look, and are available in multiple shingle colors
  • Shingle shadows and tone create an appearance that enhances the curb appeal
  • Class A fire rating

Pinnacle Pristine By Atlas

Our Rating: 8.5

From one of the largest shingle manufacturers in the U.S., Atlas provides The Pinnacle Pristine shingles; a high-performance architectural shingle that can increase the performance of your roofing system at a suitable price.

Shingles have a high-definition look and are manufactured with quality granule materials.

You also get a variety of color options from Atlas’s Natural Expressions color palettes, such as weathered wood, pewter gray, and tan. The colors have a powerful impact on the roof and last longer, thanks to their Scotchguard protection.


  • Lifetime limited warranty against manufacturing defects
  • Pinnacle Pristine shingles offer wind protection up to 130 mph, which is great for windy areas
  • Extra protection against black streaks with Scotchguard Protector by 3M
  • Access to a variety of color options under the Atlas Natural Expressions Range.

Best Weathered Wood Shingles Color Combination

One of the major advantages of installing weather wood-colored roof shingles is that they fit well with most home styles.

In general, neutral colors like beige, gray, or white can often be a good choice for siding when paired with weathered wood shingles, as they can help complement the shingles’ natural tones and create a cohesive look.

Alternatively, consider using colors that contrast with the natural tones of the shingles, such as deep greens or blues, to create a more striking and bold aesthetic. In the end, the best color combination will depend on your personal preferences and the overall design of your home.

Get Professional Weathered Wood Shingle Installation Services

Purchasing the best-weathered wood shingle is important, but it’s even more important to hire a professional contractor to install them. If the shingles are incorrectly installed, you could void manufacturer warranties on your shingles, as well as make your roof vulnerable to leaks and wind damage that could occur when poorly installed shingles blow away.

If you are looking for a shingle installer, contact the Kickapoo Roofing team. Our team is fully licensed and insured, and we are a GAF-certified roofing company, proving that we have the expertise to install GAF-weathered wood shingles. We’re not only associated with GAF, but also with other top manufacturers such as Malarkey. We have years of experience installing quality asphalt shingles roof systems, and we also offer warranties so that you can have peace of mind. Contact us today at (608) 352-8688 to discuss our services with a team member.

Weathered wood Shingles Reviewed
Skip to content