Budget-Friendly vs. Premium Shingles: Which Is The Best Value for Your Money?

Posted on July 19, 2023

Estimated Reading Time : 5 Min.

Share Now :

Budget-Friendly vs. Premium Shingles

When it comes to choosing the right roofing material for your home, asphalt shingles are the most popular option on the market. They offer durability, affordability, and a wide range of design choices. However, within the realm of asphalt shingles, there are different types available, each with its own characteristics and benefits. In this article, we will explore the two main types of asphalt shingles: 3-tab and premium shingles. We will compare the two, highlighting the features, costs, and reasons why you might consider upgrading to premium shingles from 3-tab shingles.

Understanding Asphalt Shingles

Premium shingles | kickapoo roofing

Before we delve into the comparison, let’s take a moment to understand what makes asphalt shingles such a popular choice for roofing. Asphalt shingles are made from a base mat, coated with asphalt, and embedded with mineral granules. This composition gives them their strength, durability, and resistance to harsh weather conditions. They are designed to protect your home from the elements while providing an aesthetically pleasing look.

The Types of Asphalt Shingles

There are different types of asphalt shingles available on the market, but for the purpose of this article, we will focus on 3-tab and premium shingles. These two types represent the budget-friendly and premium options, respectively, catering to different needs and budgets.

1. 3-Tab Shingles: The Budget-Friendly Option

Premium shingles | kickapoo roofing

3-Tab asphalt shingles are the most basic and affordable option in the asphalt shingle category. They get their name from the three tabs on each shingle strip, which create a uniform appearance. These shingles are lightweight, easy to install, and have been a popular choice for many years. 

Key Features of 3-Tab Shingles:

  • Basic appearance with a flat, uniform look
  • Affordable price range, typically costing around $1-$2 per square foot
  • Limited color and design options
  • Suitable for homeowners on a tight budget

Disadvantages of 3-Tab Shingles: 

  • 3-Tab shingles typically have a shorter lifespan compared to premium shingles.
  • Due to cost-cutting measures, 3-tab shingles may be made from lower-quality materials. 
  • 3-Tab shingles often come with limited warranty coverage. 

2. Premium Shingles: The Upgrade

Premium shingles | kickapoo roofing

Premium shingles, also known as luxury shingles, are a step up from 3-tab shingles in terms of quality, durability, and aesthetics. They are made using multiple layers of asphalt, which creates a more robust and visually appealing product. Premium shingles are designed to mimic the appearance of other high-end roofing materials, such as wood shakes or slate, at a fraction of the cost.

Key Features of Premium Shingles:

  • Longer lifespan of up to 30 years or more, depending on the manufacturer
  • Enhanced curb appeal with a textured, multi-dimensional look
  • Greater variety of colors, patterns, and designs
  • Higher cost compared to 3-tab shingles, typically ranging from $4-$6 per square foot
  • Ideal for homeowners seeking a more visually appealing and durable roofing option

Disadvantages of Premium Shingles

  • The initial investment can be substantial, especially for larger roofing projects.
  • Premium shingles require professional installation due to their intricate design and specific installation techniques. 
  • They require periodic maintenance to ensure their longevity and optimal performance.

Budget-Friendly vs. Premium Shingles: The Comparison

Now that we have a basic understanding of both 3-tab and premium shingles let’s compare them side by side based on a couple of key factors: lifespan, appearance, performance, and cost. 

1. Lifespan: Durability Matters

One of the most important considerations when choosing a roofing material is its lifespan. You want a roof that will stand the test of time and require minimal maintenance. In terms of durability, premium shingles have the upper hand. 

While 3-tab shingles typically last around 25 years, premium shingles offer a longer lifespan of up to 30 years or more. With proper installation and regular maintenance, premium shingles can even exceed their expected lifespan.

2. Appearance: Aesthetics Make a Difference

The appearance of your roof plays a significant role in the overall look of your home. While 3-tab shingles provide a clean and uniform appearance, premium shingles take it a step further with their textured, multi-dimensional design. 

They create depth and visual interest, mimicking the look of more expensive roofing materials like wood shakes or slate. If you want your home to make a statement and stand out in the neighborhood, premium shingles offer a more visually appealing option.

3. Performance: Resistance To Weathering 

While 3-tab shingles provide adequate protection against the elements, they may not offer the same level of performance in extreme weather conditions. They might be more prone to damage from high winds, heavy rain, or hail. Since they are prone to wind and weather impacts, they may require you to spot and repair wind damage

Premium shingles, on the other hand, are engineered to withstand harsh weather conditions better. They often have features like enhanced wind resistance, impact resistance, and better waterproofing capabilities.

4. Cost: Budget Considerations

Cost is often a determining factor when choosing any home improvement material, and roofing is no exception. 3-Tab shingles are the more budget-friendly option, costing less than $5 per square foot. On the other hand, premium shingles come at a higher price point, typically ranging closer to $10 per square foot. 

It’s important to consider your budget and long-term goals when making a decision. While premium shingles require a larger upfront investment, they offer enhanced durability and aesthetic appeal, which can increase the value of your home.

Making The Right Decision For Your Roof

It is understandable that not all homeowners have the same financial resources, and that’s where the choice between 3-tab or premium shingles becomes crucial. If you are on a tight budget and need a cost-effective roofing solution, 3-tab shingles are a viable option. They provide basic functionality and protection without breaking the bank. 

However, if you have more flexibility in your budget and are looking for a long-term investment, premium shingles offer a high-quality option that can enhance the overall value and curb appeal of your home.


In conclusion, when it comes to choosing between 3-tab and premium shingles, it’s essential to consider factors such as lifespan, appearance, cost, and budget. While 3-tab shingles are a budget-friendly option, premium shingles offer enhanced durability, aesthetics, and potential long-term value. The decision ultimately depends on your specific requirements and financial situation. 

If you’re looking for a roofing material that combines affordability with durability and visual appeal, premium shingles may be the best value for your money.

No matter which type of shingle you choose, it’s crucial to hire a reputable roofing contractor for proper installation and maintenance. A professional can guide you through the selection process, ensure a quality installation, and provide valuable advice on maximizing the lifespan of your chosen shingles.

Hire Reputable And Trustworthy Roofing Contractors To Install Asphalt Shingle Roofs

Premium shingles | kickapoo roofing

To ensure the longevity of your roof, proper installation by reputable and trusted roofing contractors is a must. The roof installation is just as important as the roofing materials. In addition, neglecting to choose professional and skilled roofers to install your roof could result in significant roof damage and costly repairs. 
So, make the wise decision and hire skilled, trusted roofing contractors to install your asphalt shingle roof. Call Kickapoo Roofing in Wisconsin today at (608) 352-8688. We are professional roofing contractors with years of experience who understand all your roofing needs and can answer all your questions.

Additional Information

If premium shingles are not within your budget, but you want a better option than 3-tab shingles, there are still ways to enhance the durability and appearance of your roof. Consider opting for architectural or dimensional shingles. They offer a middle ground between 3-tab and premium shingles. These shingles provide added durability and aesthetic appeal at a more affordable price point than premium shingles. Discuss your options with a professional roofing contractor who can provide guidance based on your specific needs and budget.

Budget-Friendly vs. Premium Shingles
Skip to content